People Magazine Praise About Book Activities Columns

Why mothers are usually awarded residential custody.

by M. Gary Neuman, LMHC

It's not fair. Recently my lawyer told me not to even attempt to fight for custody of my child because judges always choose the Mother. I've been extremely involved in my children's upbringing and the idea of seeing them only every other weekend infuriates me. It seems the courts are more interested in making sure I pay child support than spending time with my children.
 


Statistically speaking, your attorney is right. When the question of custody of children is raised, the odds are that mothers will be awarded residential custody of the children. Many judges may choose mothers for that role because of prejudice even though laws generally demand equal consideration for both parents. However, often there are sound reasons to have Mom in the role of primary residential parent.

While there are exceptions, when two people are married, it tends to be the mother who takes off from work (if she is employed outside the home) when a child is ill or needs to visit the doctor. Usually, it is the mother whose work schedule is more flexible so that she can be home in time for the dinner hour with the children. Mothers greatly outnumber fathers at school events such as parent teacher conferences. When all is said and done, fathers in general have been more involved with their children than in past generations, but as a whole lag behind their wives in time spent caring for their children. There are many exceptions but they are just that; exceptions.

When it comes time for judges to make decisions regarding custody, they must consider which parent is the "psychological parent;" the one who has been largely responsible for the general care of the child's world both physically and emotionally. In order to cause the least amount of turmoil in a child's life, courts want the least amount of change for the child. If the child is used to one parent generally caring for her, it is beneficial for that relationship to continue as it has been for years. Obviously, it may be the less involved parent who provides more nurturing. But it is difficult to see this as an outsider. Even though time spent with a child does not always equal a caring loving parent, the court usually must look for some concrete evidence indicating which parent takes the general care of the child.

However, this does not minimize the role fathers must play in children's lives. There are many fathers who are the "psychological parent", the parent whom the child relies on to discuss feelings and problems. There are those fathers who are just as involved with their children as the mother. Under those circumstances, fathers should consider requesting the court to consider them as the custodial parent.

For those who are not as involved as mothers, fathers still assume an important role in children's development and growth. The relationship with father will often speak directly to who we marry (husband), how we care for our own family, our financial success and general self-esteem. The importance of children spending time with their fathers cannot be understated.

For this reason, many custody arrangements have changed to include more liberal visitation. Instead of just every other weekend, consider one overnight visit during the school week (Thursday nights seem to work well), or two evenings each week for dinner and homework. Sharing children's vacation equally and rotating holidays has become standard in most courts. Try not to "fight it out" in court. Use mediation or ask your attorney if everyone can sit down and discuss matters in a mature non-battling manner, for the sake of the children. This gives parties the opportunity to carve out agreements especially tailored for their lifestyle instead of being placed into a general category for child custody arrangements by the judge.

I don't know if it still seems "unfair" to you after this information but consider this. Many fathers have told me that they have more time with their children after divorce than before. After all, rarely did they ever get to be alone with their children for full weekends. And often even in so called "intact" homes, children don't see one of their parents much during the week due to work and other obligations.

Make sure to bridge the gaps between spending time with your children with telephone calls, e-mail, bedtime stories over the phone. Staying in regular contact will minimize your child's difficulty in dealing with the separation.

For all of us who take pride in being fathers, divorced or not, we should consider how much time and energy we are putting into the day to day care of our children. Are we missing out on our children's upbringing using socially appropriate excuses such as work and hanging out with the guys? It would be nice to see more fathers in the library and visiting museums with children, in addition to the sports events. Let's discover new ways to be more involved and never feel as though we're watching our children grow from the sidelines.
 

Here are this month's Q/A's from Gary Neuman's award winning nationally syndicated column, Changing Families.